Justice of the Peace Mary Ann Luedecke is facing renewed scrutiny after Brewster County Sheriff Ronny Dodson disclosed that she sent an alert to regional law enforcement on October 20, 2023, warning of a so-called “First Amendment auditor” in the area—referring to Big Bend Times publisher David Flash. Luedecke has since denied sending the message. Flash formally requested a copy of the notice, but none has been provided.
Flash, a media scholar and journalist, holds a Master of Science in Digital Audience Strategy from Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication. He called the label both “false and dangerous,” warning that it undermines the essential role of journalism and misrepresents his work.
“I don’t confront people with cameras or bait public officials. I attend meetings, gather facts, and report the news,” Flash said. “Mislabeling me this way could invite retaliation or even violence—and it’s being done by the very people I’m reporting on.”
Flash moved to Fort Davis to live a peaceful life while building Big Bend Times as a media experiment. The outlet has since become the most-read local news source in the region. While he no longer lives in the area, Flash continues to cover West Texas remotely and on visits, bringing with him the perspective of a seasoned media professional who has visited government buildings on six continents without incident—except in Jeff Davis County.
“No other place in the world has treated me like this,” Flash said. “Here, a local judge tried to detain me without cause, yelled ‘You’re detained!’ inside the courthouse, and has now apparently alerted law enforcement about me behind my back.”
Flash says he records courthouse interactions for his own protection. “If I didn’t record, what would they say happened?” he said. “I’m not confrontational, but Jeff Davis County officials have repeatedly threatened to charge me with crimes simply for doing journalism.”
Recently, Big Bend Times published an investigative story questioning Luedecke’s use of a $70,000 county-issued 2023 Ram Cummins 4×4 truck. Flash contacted every other justice of the peace in the tri-county area to ask if they had a county-furnished vehicle. None did, and all offices responded professionally.
“That’s how normal public officials behave,” Flash said. “Luedecke’s reaction was not normal.”
Flash is a self-described media nerd who studies historic publishers like Amon Carter, Joseph Pulitzer, E.W. Scripps, and Dorothy Schiff, while keeping up with modern thinkers such as Amanda Lotz and David Bianculli. He reports on government meetings, community events, and local sports, with the goal of building sustainable local media that serves the public without relying on government favoritism or advertising.
“I’m trying to do what the press is supposed to do—shine light, not create conflict,” Flash said. “But when a judge secretly paints you as a threat for doing your job, that’s not just unethical. It’s dangerous.”
1 Comment